Lessons Learned from Failed Tender Projects (and How to Avoid Them)

The first red flag appeared when one of the shortlisted suppliers sent in a bid filled with vague promises and incomplete numbers. Instead of disqualifying them, my team allowed them to “clarify later” because we were running behind schedule.

That small act of leniency created a ripple effect.

Then came the evaluation phase. The criteria hadn’t been properly spelled out into objective metrics, so two key stakeholders disagreed on the priority metrics. Finance insisted on cost optimization, while Operations pushed hard for performance and lead time. Both were right, yet both were pulling in different directions since the set criteria wasn’t clear. The arguments dragged the process and confidence in the tender slowly eroded.

By the time we selected a supplier, top leadership didn’t fully trust our recommendation and honestly, neither did I. Needless to say, the supplier underperformed and the project failed. Not due solely to the supplier, but because the tender process itself had been compromised.

The Real Lessons That Stuck With Me

✔️ Never ignore incomplete or unclear bids: If a supplier can’t get their proposal right, don’t expect them to suddenly improve after contract award. Ambiguity spells danger. Clarity is competence.

✔️ Align key stakeholders early: A tender is not just procurement’s job and misaligned priorities can sink the project before the first PO is issued.

✔️ Use clear, objective evaluation criteria: Before the tender is sent out, be clear on the evaluation criteria, factor in necessary metrics and make it as objective as possible.

✔️ Start the process as early as possible: Rushing leads to shortcuts. Shortcuts lead to blind spots. And blind spots lead to failed tenders.

✔️ Don’t assume silence means agreement: When stakeholders nod without real input, expect disagreements later. Ask questions. Get commitments. Document decisions.

✔️ Keep communication brutally transparent: A tender is only as strong as the information shared. The moment key details are held back, the process is weakened.

Failed tenders are painful but they’re also powerful teachers. If you’ve ever managed a project that completely collapsed, don’t bury the experience. Use it. Share it. Let it shape stronger, smarter procurement decisions.

Need procurement specific training? Reach out to support@efemini.com and we'll get you sorted.